Quote #4

In chapter 15 of "The Scarlet Letter" by Nathaniel Hawthorne I came across a statement that somewhat tied in with a discussion I had in class today. At this point in the story, the author is talking about Pearl and the possible inheritance of evil. "With all these sterling attributes, thought Hester, the evil which she inherited from her mother must be great indeed, if a noble woman do not grow out of this elfish child." This same particular topic was brought up in class today. We had a bit of a debate whether Pearl could have actually done something wrong in this story or if she was the only innocent one.

I would have to say that yes I agree with the many students in my class who said something along the lines of "Well, Pearl couldn't help that she was born that way." She cannot control what she inherits at all. However, it's up to Hester to teach Pearl the right ways and to not let Pearl follow in Hester's foot steps. Once Pearl is old enough to understand what is right or wrong then it will definately be her fault for any wrongdoings. While she is a young child though, townspeople shouldn't assume that she will be just like her mother. It's not fair towards Pearl at all to recieve the same punishment as Hester.

Hester Prynne made the mistake when creating this child with the minister. However, there should be much less ridicule put upon Pearl. That's especially true when someone such is the minister deserves just as much punishment as Hester and recieves none.